AN INVESTIGATION OF THE SO-CALLED SECOND STYLE AT SAQQARA IN THE LATER OLD KINGDOM AND FIRST INTERMEDIATE PERIOD
Degree type
Graduate group
Discipline
History
History
Subject
Egyptology
First Intermediate Period
Late Old Kingdom
Saqqara
Second Style
Funder
Grant number
License
Copyright date
Distributor
Related resources
Author
Contributor
Abstract
In the late Old Kingdom, an unusual corpus of artistic production, royal and non-royal, appeared on the scene. Funerary statuary and reliefs from that time display atypical proportions when depicting aspects of the human form: limbs appear longer, eyes and heads seem larger. Overall, these changes, which appear to distort traditional canons, exude pervasive dynamism and expressiveness. In the past, art historians and Egyptologists dismissed the phenomenon as “bad art” resulting from political decentralization and cultural decline. Then two scholars in particular, Edna Russmann and Edward Brovarski, reevaluated these artistic productions, assessing them as voluntary innovations. Such manner of representation has been called the “Second Style.” This dissertation set out to review the phenomenon in theoretical terms and determined its existence. It then tested whether the change in artistic canons to represent the human form could be measured, reaching the conclusion that this area needs further and more sophisticated testing. The next part of the research was dedicated to assessing and verifying known occurrences of the style in statuary and relief at Saqqara, as well as surveying the archaeological context for unreported occurrences. The results determined the earliest occurrences within the site and led to observations regarding the distribution of the occurrences. The finds revealed an early onset of the style with diffused use of its idiosyncratic elements during the Fifth Dynasty, which seemingly emerged in the royal workshops as early as the reign of Raneferef, per Prakash’s previous assessment of the phenomenon in the royal realm. During the Sixth Dynasty, the style found favor with the courtiers, with its employment in private statuary reaching its peak during the reign of Pepy II. The Second Style then continued to exert its influence on the production of statuary and relief of the Middle and Upper Egyptian sites, in particular during the First Intermediate Period and well into the early Middle Kingdom, when the artistic representations of the upcoming Theban dynasty show some of the style characteristics. This study may serve as the basis for a number of further investigations, such as female representation in the art of the time, and more.