When Using Knowledge Can Hurt Performance: The Value of Organizational Capabilities in a Management Consulting Company

Thumbnail Image
Penn collection
Management Papers
Degree type
knowledge sharing
knowledge transfer
organizational capabilities
management consulting
competitive bidding
Business Administration, Management, and Operations
Management Information Systems
Training and Development
Grant number
Copyright date
Related resources
Haas, Martine
Hansen, Morten T

This paper explores the possibility that utilizing the firm's knowledge resources to complete important tasks can backfire and undermine competitive performance. Drawing on organizational capabilities and knowledge-sharing research, we develop a situated performance view that holds that the value of obtaining and using knowledge within a firm depends on the task situation. Using a data set of 182 sales proposals for client work in a management consulting company, we show that sales teams that had varying needs to learn and differentiate themselves from competitors derived different levels of value from obtaining and using electronic documents and advice from colleagues. Highly experienced teams were more likely than inexperienced teams to lose the sales bids if they utilized such knowledge. Teams that had a high need to differentiate themselves from competitors also had a lower chance of winning if they utilized electronic documents. There were situations, however, where teams performed better if they utilized the firm's knowledge resources. These results suggest that competitive performance depends not on how much firms know but on how they use what they know.

Date Range for Data Collection (Start Date)
Date Range for Data Collection (End Date)
Digital Object Identifier
Series name and number
Publication date
Journal title
Strategic Management Journal
Volume number
Issue number
Publisher DOI
Journal Issue
Recommended citation