Departmental Papers (Classical Studies)

Document Type

Working Paper

Date of this Version

2014

Abstract

In this annotated catalogue of the 522 occurrences of the expression politeia in the Politics of Aristotle, I present my view of what Aristotle’s intent was in each occurrence—citizenship, citizen body, arrangement of offices or constitution, or regime—except where I find that the text is inexplicit. I have compared my results especially with the Sinclair-Saunders translation and occasionally with Bonitz’s Index Aristotelicus and with the translations of Jowett, Newman, Robinson, Saunders in the Clarendon Aristotle, and Simpson, along with other works.

Aristotle’s treatment of the politeia sometimes has been connected with modern constitutionalism in the form of the written constitution or arrangement of offices. Writing a constitution or drawing up an arrangement of offices sometimes does not have the stabilizing effects for which the drafters and others occasionally hope. Readers of the Politics who use the catalogue will find that Aristotle had stability much on his mind and apparently understood that stability required more than a certain arrangement of offices or constitution in the current sense.

Comments

All of the materials may be downloaded in in full from the main "Download" button or separately in "Additional Files."

© J. J. Mulhern 2014

Related work: Mulhern, J. J. (2015). Politeia in Greek literature, inscriptions, and in Aristotle's Politics: Reflections on translation and interpretation (Ch. 5). In T. Lockwood & T. Samaras (Eds.), Aristotle's Politics: A Critical Guide (pp. 84-102). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. http://www.cambridge.org/us/academic/subjects/philosophy/classical-philosophy/aristotles-politics-critical-guide

Additional Files

Polcat.abs.pdf (77 kB)
Abstract

Polcatintro.pdf (168 kB)
Introduction

polcat.i.tab.rep.pdf (79 kB)
Book I

polcat ii tab rep.pdf (119 kB)
Book II

polcat.iii.tab.rep.pdf (112 kB)
Book III

Polcat iv tab rep.pdf (156 kB)
Book IV

Polcat v tab rep.pdf (180 kB)
Book V

polcat.vi.tab.rep.pdf (106 kB)
Book VI

Polcat.vii.tab.rep.pdf (103 kB)
Book VII

polcat.viii.tab.rep.pdf (80 kB)
Book VIII

Share

COinS
 

Date Posted: 26 August 2014