Departmental Papers (ASC)

Document Type

Journal Article

Date of this Version

January 2001

Publication Source

Cardozo Law Review





Start Page


Last Page



Every new technology transforms the world around it. A century ago, in a gentle preface to his novel Under the Greenwood Tree Thomas Hardy wrote of the transformation of little church orchestras in village England. Humble and amateur community instrumentalists were being displaced by an "isolated organist" employing a newly manufactured and more cheaply distributed technology, the harmonium or barrel organ. The new device presented certain advantages in control and accomplishment, but, he suggested, the change caused the stultification of the clergy's aims and resulted in loss of interest among parishioners. In these tiny hamlets the technology of musical development had consequences for participation, organization of the institution, the nature of the music that was played, and, Hardy seemed to be saying, for country life as well. Of these multiple and small transformations major changes in society take place.

Copyright/Permission Statement

Publisher URL:


NOTE: At the time of publication, author Monroe Price was affiliated with the Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law, Yeshiva University. Currently(February, 2008), he is an Adjunct Full Professor at the Annenberg School for Communication at the University of Pennsylvania.



Date Posted: 13 February 2008

This document has been peer reviewed.