Departmental Papers (ASC)

Document Type

Journal Article

Date of this Version

7-2009

Publication Source

International Journal of General Systems

Volume

38

Issue

6

Start Page

669

Last Page

680

DOI

10.1080/03081070902993160

Abstract

This paper addresses misconceptions of the multi-variate interaction-information measure Q, which several authors have reinvented since its proposal by McGill (1954), giving it a variety of names and interpretations. McGill’s measure claimed to quantify the amount of information of interactions among three or more variables in complex systems. In (Krippendorff, 1980), I raised doubts about the validity of Q and its relatives. The chief problem that Q-measures fail to recognize is that complex interactions tend to involve circularities and the probability distributions characterizing such circularities cannot be obtained by products of probabilities, which underlie information theory as far as developed by Shannon (Shannon & Weaver, 1949). I argued that Q-measures are mere arithmetic artifacts, and proposed an algorithmic solution to measuring the amount of information in the interactions within complex systems, now widely accepted. The paper responds to Leydesdorff’s (2009) “Interaction information: Linear and nonlinear interpretations,” published in the current issue of this journal and preceding discussions of these issues on the Cybernetics Discussion Group CYBCOM and personal correspondence involving Jakulin (2009). It prefers to rely on demonstrations with numerical data over abstract interpretations of mathematical forms that can so easily entrap scholars into believing that they measure something real without considering evidence to the contrary.

Copyright/Permission Statement

This article was published in the International Journal of General Systems, 2009, © Taylor & Francis, available online at: http://www.tandfonline.com/10.1080/03081070902993160.

Keywords

Information Theory, Complex Systems, Interaction Information, Cybernetics. Decomposition

 

Date Posted: 06 September 2013

This document has been peer reviewed.